- Published
- Updated
- 9 min read

TL;DR: Brands are adding AI to creator marketing fast, and creator ad spend still grew 26% in 2025 to a projected $37 billion. AI can make content cheaply. It cannot make an owned audience: real people who chose you and that you can reach directly. That is what keeps a creator worth paying.
Updated October 2026: the first version led with a 77% budget-shift figure and consumer-preference numbers from an agency-run survey. We could not confirm them with an independent source, so they are out and the title has changed.
You have probably seen a headline that says brands are moving creator money to AI-made influencers. Some of that is real. Brands are testing AI in every part of creator marketing. But the money is not leaving creators. It is moving toward the creators who bring something a model cannot generate, and that something is an owned audience.
Here is what the published numbers say, what the law now requires in one big market, and what a creator can do this week to be on the right side of it.
Are brands really moving creator budgets to AI?
They are adding AI, and they are still spending more on creators. Both are true at once.
The IAB, the ad industry's trade body, projects that U.S. "creator economy ad spend is projected to reach $37 billion in 2025," which is "a 26% increase year-over-year," and "about 4x faster than the media industry overall." It also found that "Nearly half (48%) of ad spenders consider creators a "must buy," ranking only behind social media and paid search." (IAB (opens in a new tab)) Trade press reported the same figures when the report came out. (TV Technology (opens in a new tab))
On AI, the same IAB release says "Nearly three-in-four creator ad buyers are already using or planning to use AI within the next year," and "95% of advertisers have concerns about using AI in creator marketing overall." (IAB (opens in a new tab))
Put those side by side. Buyers are using AI for the work around creator marketing, they are worried about it, and they keep raising what they pay real creators. That is not a robot takeover. It is brands sorting what can be automated from what cannot, and an owned audience sits firmly on the side that cannot.
What are brands actually paying creators for?
When a brand pays you, it is buying two things on one invoice.
The first is the content: the video, the photo, the caption, the look, the posting schedule. AI can now make a lot of that, cheaply. If the only thing you sell is "I make content that looks like this," you are competing with a tool that never sleeps.
The second is the relationship: a group of real people who chose to follow you and believe what you tell them. Nobody can prompt that into existence. And the part of it you can reach without a platform's permission, your list, your site, your community, is your owned audience.
That is the real line in this story. Not human versus AI. Replaceable content versus an owned audience.
Do audiences want AI-made creator content?
They want to know when they are looking at it. Pew Research Center surveyed 5,023 U.S. adults in June 2025 and found "most Americans (76%) say it's extremely or very important to be able to tell if pictures, videos and text were made by AI or people." It also found "53% of Americans are not too or not at all confident they can detect if something is made by AI versus a person." (Pew Research Center (opens in a new tab))
People want to know who made what, and most of them do not trust themselves to spot it. A creator with an owned audience, people who know them and hear from them directly, has an advantage a synthetic account cannot buy.
Why is a synthetic creator the most rented asset of all?
A fully AI-generated influencer usually lives on one or two platforms and nowhere else. No list, no site, no direct channel. Its whole audience is a number on someone else's dashboard. It has followers but no owned audience. That is platform risk in its purest form.
Platforms can and do change the rules. On July 15, 2025, YouTube renamed its "repetitious content" monetization policy to "inauthentic content," "to better clarify this includes content that is repetitive or mass-produced," and said that kind of content "has always been ineligible for monetization." (YouTube Help (opens in a new tab)) YouTube's terms also say it "reserves the right to suspend or terminate your Google account or your access to all or part of the Service" in certain cases. (YouTube Terms of Service (opens in a new tab))
Our first version described one AI influencer run by an agency and a batch of AI channels wiped out. I have taken those details out rather than repeat agency and tool-vendor numbers. The point does not need them: a following that exists only on a platform belongs to the platform. That is as true for a human creator as for a synthetic one, and it is why an owned audience matters for both.
We wrote more on the YouTube side in YouTube's definition of template content.
What does New York's synthetic performer law require?
New York now requires a label when an ad uses a digital human that is not a real person. Governor Hochul signed S.8420-A on December 11, 2025, as chapter 617. (New York State Senate (opens in a new tab))
The key parts
- What counts. A "synthetic performer" is a digitally created asset made or changed by computer, "using generative artificial intelligence or a software algorithm," intended to look like a human performer "who is not recognizable as any identifiable natural performer."
- The duty. A person with actual knowledge of its use in an ad "shall conspicuously disclose in such advertisement that a synthetic performer is in such advertisement."
- Penalties. "A civil penalty of one thousand dollars for a first violation" and "five thousand dollars for any subsequent violation."
- When. It takes effect "on the one hundred eightieth day after it shall have become a law," which put the start date at June 9, 2026.
All four points come from the bill text. (New York State Senate (opens in a new tab)) Our first version described the effective date correctly; it has now passed, so the rule is live.
What about the federal executive order?
On December 11, 2025, the White House issued "Ensuring a National Policy Framework for Artificial Intelligence." It directs the Attorney General to set up an AI Litigation Task Force "whose sole responsibility shall be to challenge State AI laws" that conflict with federal policy. (The White House (opens in a new tab)) Our first version said the order tries to "pause" state laws. It does not pause anything by itself; it directs challenges and reviews. Until a court or Congress says otherwise, assume the New York rule applies to ads shown there.
Disclosing brand deals still applies
Separate from AI labels, the FTC tells influencers to "Disclose when you have any financial, employment, personal, or family relationship with a brand," and to "Place it so it's hard to miss." (Federal Trade Commission (opens in a new tab)) Honest labels on both fronts protect the trust that makes your owned audience worth anything.
We covered the ad side of this in New York's AI actor disclosure rule.
What does an owned audience actually look like?
An owned audience is the group of people you can reach without asking a platform. In practice that is three things:
- Your own domain. A site at your name, which no platform can rename or switch off. If you do not have one, start with a free site at kiefstud.io (opens in a new tab).
- Your own list. Email addresses people gave you on purpose, exportable any time.
- Your own checkout. Products, memberships or downloads sold where you hold the customer record.
Run the list by the rules. The FTC's CAN-SPAM guide says "You must honor a recipient's opt-out request within 10 business days," and "Your message must include your valid physical postal address." (Federal Trade Commission (opens in a new tab)) A list built honestly is an owned audience you can keep for years.
My wife Amelia, Kief Studio's co-founder and CEO, compared the returns in the ROI of a website versus social media (opens in a new tab). I wrote up what a free website can and cannot do for a small business (opens in a new tab).
How do you show a brand your owned audience is real?
Brands are getting more careful about what they pay for. Give them evidence of an owned audience instead of a follower count.
- List size and growth. How many subscribers, and how many joined your owned audience in the last 90 days.
- Engagement you measure yourself. Replies, clicks and sales from your own emails and pages, not just platform likes.
- Where people come from. Which posts drive signups to your site. That shows your social reach turns into an owned audience.
- A clear disclosure habit. Show past sponsored posts with visible labels. It tells a brand you will not put them at risk.
Offer a brand a placement in front of your owned audience, in your newsletter or on your site, alongside the social post. That is inventory a synthetic creator cannot sell, because it does not have an owned audience to sell it to.
What should a creator do this week?
- Check who owns your domain. If you do not have one, register it in your own name.
- Put one signup link in every bio. It is the front door to your owned audience. Give people a reason to join: a checklist, early access, a behind-the-scenes note.
- Export your list. Keep a copy of your owned audience off the email platform, and repeat monthly.
- Write a one-page media kit with your list numbers and site traffic, not just follower counts.
- Label everything honestly. Sponsored posts per the FTC, and any synthetic performer in an ad shown in New York.
AI makes content cheap. That makes the relationship more valuable, not less. An owned audience is the asset; the content is the line item.
Frequently asked questions
Are brands replacing human creators with AI?
Not on the published numbers, and not creators with an owned audience. The IAB projects U.S. creator ad spend rose 26% in 2025 to $37 billion, while three in four buyers use or plan to use AI and 95% have concerns about it.
What is an owned audience?
An owned audience is the people you can reach without a platform's permission: your email list, your site on your own domain and your own checkout. You can export it and take it with you.
Do I have to label AI-generated people in ads?
In New York, yes, if you know an ad uses a synthetic performer. The law took effect June 9, 2026, with civil penalties of $1,000 for a first violation and $5,000 after that.
Did the federal executive order cancel New York's law?
No. The December 11, 2025 order directs a federal task force to challenge state AI laws. It does not pause or void any law by itself.
Can AI influencers be demonetized?
Any channel can. YouTube's inauthentic content policy covers repetitive or mass-produced content, and its terms allow it to suspend or terminate accounts in certain cases.
How big does an owned audience need to be before brands care?
There is no published threshold. Show real numbers: subscribers, recent growth and the clicks or sales your emails drive. Honest small numbers beat inflated follower counts.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Kief Studio is not a law firm, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws and regulations change, so check the current text and talk with a licensed Massachusetts attorney about your situation.
Where we fit
Kief Studio supports creators on the technical side, the way our creator services note puts it: you create, we handle the tech. If you want a simple site fast, kiefstud.io (opens in a new tab) is the quicker door into the same studio. When the site has to do more, we build it, host it on dedicated infrastructure and keep it running.
For artists and streamers, our art and illustration work covers emotes, channel art and cover art, plus portfolio sites that sell prints, originals and commissions. When a shop outgrows a first merch store, our custom ecommerce work connects checkout, payments and inventory. And if keeping the site current has become a second job, managed website operations means we host it, publish on a schedule and watch it.
First conversation is free. No commitment.




