Kief Studio

Your Next Hire Costs $140,000 or More. The Real Cost of Hiring, and What to Do When You Can't Find Them.

Support

  • Published
  • Updated
  • 8 min read
Violet and gold smoke curls through a single golden beam on a pure black background.

TL;DR: The cost of hiring a $100,000 employee is closer to $147,500 in the first year once you add benefits at the national average share and a typical cost per hire. And most small business owners who are hiring still report few or no qualified applicants. Before you post the job, decide whether you need a person, a partner or a fix to the work itself.

The cost of hiring is bigger than the salary line, and the search is harder than it should be. That is the short version of what the National Federation of Independent Business keeps reporting about small business hiring this year. If you have a role that has been open for months, the numbers below will not surprise you. They might change what you do next.

I want to walk through the real math on one hire, what the hiring data says right now, and the three options an owner actually has when the right person will not show up.

Update, October 2026: we first published this note in March 2026. We have updated the hiring and compensation figures to the latest NFIB, Bureau of Labor Statistics and KFF releases, corrected how we described the "labor quality" trend, and removed statistics we could not trace to a primary source.

What does the hiring data say right now?

In its February 2026 jobs report, NFIB found that 54% of owners were hiring or trying to hire, and "Forty-six percent (85% of those hiring or trying to hire) of owners reported few or no qualified applicants for the positions they were trying to fill." A net 34% reported raising compensation, "the highest level since March 2025," while a net 12% planned to create new jobs, "the lowest level since May 2025." (NFIB, February 2026 Jobs Report (opens in a new tab))

Seven months later, the picture had not improved. NFIB's September 2026 report says "Forty-five percent (87% of those hiring or trying to hire) of owners reported few or no qualified applicants," and that reports of labor quality or availability as the single most important problem "rose 3 points in September to 26%, 14 points above the historical average." (NFIB, September 2026 Jobs Report (opens in a new tab))

A correction on "labor quality"

Our March note read February's low "labor quality" number as owners giving up on hiring. That was a guess, and the later data does not support it. NFIB revised the category in June 2026 to "Quality or Availability of Labor," and by September it was back up to 26%. Owners did not stop caring about finding people. The search simply stayed hard.

What is the real cost of hiring one employee?

Start with the salary, then add what the salary does not show. The cost of hiring has three parts: compensation, finding the person, and the months before they are fully productive.

Benefits and payroll costs

The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that for private industry workers in June 2026, total employer compensation averaged $46.89 per hour, with wages and salaries at $32.82, or "70.0 percent of employer costs," and benefits accounting for "the remaining 30.0 percent." (Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employer Costs for Employee Compensation (opens in a new tab))

If your benefits package matches that national average share, a $100,000 salary means about $142,900 in total compensation, because $100,000 is 70% of $142,857. Your number will differ. A shop that offers family health coverage, a retirement match and generous paid leave can run above average, and a shop with fewer benefits below it. Run it with your own package.

Health coverage keeps climbing

Health insurance is the benefit that moves the most. KFF's 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey found that "Annual premiums for employer-sponsored family health coverage reached $28,303 this year, 5% higher than in 2025," with single coverage averaging $9,804. (KFF (opens in a new tab)) Every person already on your payroll got more expensive this year, before you added anyone.

The cost of finding the person

Then there is the search itself. According to SHRM benchmarking data, "the average cost per hire was nearly $4,700." The same article notes that "many employers estimate the total cost to hire a new employee can be three to four times the position's salary," which is an estimate, not a benchmark. (SHRM (opens in a new tab)) SHRM's 2026 benchmarking brief adds that "Time-to-fill has decreased to a median of 39 calendar days for nonexecutive positions." (SHRM (opens in a new tab))

Putting the cost of hiring together

For a $100,000 role, at the national average benefit share:

  • Total compensation: about $142,900
  • Cost per hire: about $4,700
  • First-year total: about $147,500, before equipment, software seats, training time and the weeks it takes a new person to get up to speed

That is where the title comes from. The cost of hiring a $100,000 person is roughly $140,000 to $150,000 in year one, and more if you hire wrong and have to do it twice.

Why does a bad hire make the cost of hiring worse?

Because you pay the cost of hiring twice: the search again, plus the salary you spent while finding out. If a role takes 39 days to fill at the median and a few months to judge, a wrong hire can cost you half a year of salary, two rounds of recruiting and the work that did not get done in between.

We are not going to quote a single "cost of a bad hire" percentage. The ones that circulate online rarely trace back to a primary source. The honest version is that it depends on the role, and you can estimate it yourself: months of salary paid before you knew, plus a second cost per hire, plus the cost of the work that slipped.

What are your options when you cannot find the right person?

There are three, and the right answer depends on the work.

Option 1: hire, but narrow the role

Many open roles are three jobs in one listing. A developer who also runs IT, manages the website and handles security is hard to find because that person is rare. Split the job. Hire for the part that needs a full-time person in your building, and handle the rest another way.

Option 2: partner for the specialist work

A hire fills a seat. A partner fills a gap, and you skip most of the cost of hiring for work you only need a few days a month. For work that needs deep skill a few days a month, such as security reviews, a system integration or a new application, a partner can be cheaper than carrying a full salary 52 weeks a year. The test is simple: can you describe the outcome you want? If you can, a good partner can deliver it. If you cannot, start with advice before you buy either.

Option 3: change the work

Sometimes the role exists because people are doing by hand what software should do. Copying orders between systems, chasing paperwork, building the same report every week. Fixing that avoids the cost of hiring for the role entirely, and it does not replace anyone. It frees the people you have for the work that needs them. I wrote on my own site about why we build agents instead of hiring for some jobs (opens in a new tab), and we cover the operator side in the technical demands grew, your team didn't.

How do you decide between hiring and partnering?

Here is a hypothetical. A twelve-person engineering firm in Westborough has had a "developer and IT manager" job posted for four months. The cost of hiring that person at $100,000 is about $147,500 in year one. When the owner lists what the role actually does, it is three things: keep laptops and accounts running, maintain a customer portal, and connect the project system to accounting.

  1. Laptops and accounts are steady weekly work. That might justify a part-time or junior hire, or a managed service.
  2. The customer portal needs a developer a few days a month, not forty hours a week.
  3. The accounting connection is a one-time integration with monitoring after.

Split that way, the owner might hire one easier-to-find person and partner for the rest, and the four-month search ends. Your split will look different. The point is to write the role down by task before you decide.

How do you lower the cost of hiring when you do hire?

If a hire is the right call, a few habits keep the cost of hiring down:

  • Write the job by task, not by title. A clear list of weekly work attracts people who can do it and filters out people who cannot.
  • Use your own network first. Referrals from staff, customers and suppliers often cost less than paid job boards and recruiters.
  • Price the full package before you post. Run your own benefits against the salary so the offer you can afford is the offer you advertise.
  • Plan the first 90 days. Most of the hidden cost of hiring is the slow start. Have the accounts, the documentation and a person to answer questions ready on day one.

Frequently asked questions

What is the true cost of hiring an employee?

Salary plus benefits, plus recruiting. At the national average, wages are 70% of employer compensation costs, so a $100,000 salary is about $142,900 in total compensation before recruiting.

How much does it cost to recruit one person?

SHRM benchmarking data put the average cost per hire at nearly $4,700. Specialized and executive roles cost much more.

How long does it take to fill a job?

SHRM's 2026 brief reports a median of 39 calendar days for nonexecutive positions. Hard-to-fill technical roles often take longer.

Why can't small businesses find qualified applicants?

NFIB's September 2026 report found 87% of owners hiring or trying to hire reported few or no qualified applicants. Narrowing the role often widens the pool.

Is a partner cheaper than a hire?

For specialist work needed a few days a month, often yes. For steady daily work in your building, a hire usually makes more sense. Compare both against the full cost of hiring.

Should I raise pay to fill the role?

Sometimes. Many owners have: NFIB reported a net 28% raised compensation in September 2026. Check whether the job description is the real problem first.

Where we fit

Kief Studio is for owners who need senior technical work without carrying a full team for every discipline. Our managed technology services host your systems on LTFI, the system we built, and keep them running, patched and watched, so you have one accountable studio instead of a pile of vendors. If you are facing a hire-or-partner decision, technology advisory reviews your systems, goals and constraints and gives you a plan in plain language. You can read more in our guide to managed services.

Some of our client relationships go back more than 13 years. One client reported 400% revenue growth after we rebuilt their digital operations, and another needed 121 million records indexed with sub-second search. Each started with someone writing down what the work actually was.

First conversation is free. No commitment.

Send us the job description you can't fill

Related articles

  1. Support

    Small Business Health Insurance in 2026: Similar Premiums, Thinner Cover, and the Real Cost of Your Next Hire

    Small business health insurance in 2026: what KFF and BLS data show about premiums, deductibles and rate hikes, and how to price your next hire at full cost.

    Brian Gagne

  2. Support

    Quarterly Business Review With Your Technology Partner: What a Useful One Covers

    What an IT quarterly business review with your technology partner should cover: what broke, what was fixed, risks, spend, next quarter, and a one-page agenda.

    Amelia Gagne

  3. Support

    Build the Team or Find the Partner: How to Decide Whether to Hire or Partner

    Hire or partner for technical work: what a seat really costs, when steady demand justifies a hire, what to always own, and Massachusetts contractor rules.

    Amelia Gagne