Kief Studio

Jack Dorsey Says AI Should Replace Middle Management. That's Most of the Agency Model.

Automate

  • Published
  • Updated
  • 10 min read
Short violet and gold light streaks drift above and below one bright horizontal path on a black background.

TL;DR: Jack Dorsey and Roelof Botha argue that AI can do the coordination work middle management exists to do. Block cut more than 4,000 jobs first. The evidence that AI already replaces middle management is thin, but clients now price agencies as if it does. Agencies that do the work, not route it, hold their value.

Middle management is the layer Jack Dorsey wants AI to replace, and if you run an agency, that layer is most of what you sell. Account directors, project managers, producers, coordinators. The people who turn what the client said into what the team builds, then turn it back into what the client wanted.

That work matters. I have run projects for a long time and the coordination is often the hardest part. But when a public company CEO says software can do it, every client who reads the essay starts doing math on your retainer. So let's look at what was actually said, what the numbers support, and what an agency owner can do about it this quarter.

What did Jack Dorsey actually say about middle management?

On March 31, 2026, Block published "From Hierarchy to Intelligence," written by Jack Dorsey and Roelof Botha. (Block (opens in a new tab)) The essay walks from the Roman legion through the Prussian staff system to the modern company, and treats hierarchy as an information routing protocol built around one human limit: a leader can manage somewhere between three and eight people.

The core claim is plain. "Hierarchy and middle management impede information flow," the authors write. They argue AI is the first technology that can "maintain a continuously updated model of an entire business and use it to coordinate work in ways that previously required humans relaying information through layers of management." (Block (opens in a new tab))

Put simply, they are not saying AI writes better code than your developers. They are saying AI can do the routing. That is a direct shot at middle management, and it is the part an agency owner should read twice.

The three roles that replace middle management

The essay normalizes the company down to three roles. (Block (opens in a new tab))

  • Individual contributors who build and operate the product and the systems behind it.
  • Directly responsible individuals who own a specific problem or customer outcome for a set period, with authority to pull resources.
  • Player-coaches who still build, and also develop the people around them. In the essay's words, they replace the traditional manager "whose primary job was information routing."

Notice what is missing: a tier whose whole job is status. No middle management layer that only relays. Every role in that model ships something. Hold that thought, because it is the test your clients are about to apply to you.

Why does the market reward cutting middle management?

Because Block did it before it wrote about it. In February 2026 the company said it was laying off more than 4,000 people, taking the workforce to just under 6,000, and Dorsey's shareholder letter named "intelligence tools" as the reason. (CNN (opens in a new tab))

Executive seen from behind in a calm boardroom at dusk, looking at a wall screen with a blurred chart of company layers
Block's cut showed boards a trade: fewer coordinators, higher gross profit, a rising stock.

This was not a company in trouble. Dorsey wrote that "our business is strong… gross profit continues to grow," and predicted that within the next year "the majority of companies will reach the same conclusion." (CNN (opens in a new tab)) Fortune reported fourth quarter gross profit of $2.87 billion, up 24% year over year, and the stock up nearly 18% the next day. (Fortune (opens in a new tab))

Line those two facts up. A profitable company cut about 40% of its people, said AI was why, and investors paid it for doing so. Every board in America saw that trade, and plenty of them will try the same cut to middle management. Your clients' boards saw it too.

Is AI actually replacing middle management yet?

Mostly no, and the data on that is better than the headlines. Here is what the research says, side by side.

Project manager's hands on a laptop beside a notebook, a blurred status recap on screen in a quiet agency office
AI can draft the status recap, but most cuts to middle management are bets on future results.
  • Cuts come before results. A Harvard Business Review survey of 1,006 global executives in December 2025 found that "60% of organizations have already reduced headcount in anticipation of AI's future impact," as Sherwood News reported it. (Harvard Business Review (opens in a new tab); Sherwood News (opens in a new tab)) In anticipation. Not because the tools already did the job.
  • Most firms see no employment effect. Surveys of nearly 6,000 CEOs, CFOs and senior finance managers in the US, UK, Germany and Australia found that "more than 90 percent of executives report no effect of AI use on employment over the past three years." (National Bureau of Economic Research (opens in a new tab))
  • Many regret it. Forrester found that 55% of employers regret laying off staff because of AI, and warned that "too often, company management lays off employees based on the future promise of AI." (Computerworld (opens in a new tab))

So the honest read is this: AI can help a lot with routing, summaries and status, but most companies cutting middle management are betting on future results, not banking current ones.

What the rehiring numbers say

The rebound is already being forecast. Gartner predicted in February 2026 that half of companies that reduced customer service headcount due to AI will rehire staff by 2027 to perform similar functions. (CX Dive (opens in a new tab)) Forrester's future of work predictions say half of AI-attributed layoffs are likely to be reversed, often "offshore or at lower salary." (The Register (opens in a new tab))

Read that carefully. The work comes back. The price does not. That is the part that should worry an agency more than the cuts themselves.

Why is the agency model exposed when middle management goes?

Strip the titles off and a lot of agencies work like this: the client pays the agency, the agency coordinates a team, the team does the work, and the margin lives in the coordination. That coordination layer is middle management with a client logo on the status report.

Forrester's agency forecast puts numbers on the pressure. "After an average 8% headcount cut in 2025, Forrester now forecasts a 15% reduction in 2026." It also says 85% of US B2C marketing executives plan to review their media agencies in 2026. (Forrester (opens in a new tab))

Average agency headcount cut in 2025
8%
Agency headcount reduction forecast for 2026
15%
US B2C marketing executives planning to review their media agencies in 2026
85%

Agencies are cutting staff and clients are reviewing who they pay (Forrester, Predictions 2026)

Agency jobs are going, and clients are reviewing who they pay. That is the backdrop for every renewal conversation you have next year.

Then a client's CEO reads that middle management slows a company down. From where they sit, your account layer looks like the same thing, billed by the hour. That is unfair to a good account team, and it is still how the invoice gets read.

What clients will ask about middle management fees

Forrester tells CMOs to renegotiate "to reflect the solutions that agencies now offer, rather than just the time spent delivering them." (Forrester (opens in a new tab)) In practice that means three questions on your next call:

  1. What part of this retainer is people doing the work, and what part is people managing the people?
  2. Could software produce the status updates, recaps and timelines we pay for?
  3. If we cut the coordination hours, what would we lose?

If your answer to the third question is "not much," the client will find out on their own. Better that you find out first.

What should an agency owner do about middle management this quarter?

You do not need to fire your account team. You need to know which hours are routing and which are making, and then price the making. Here is how I would run it.

A one-week audit of coordination hours

  1. Tag every hour for five working days. Two tags only: "make" (writing, designing, coding, testing, deploying, fixing) and "route" (status calls, recaps, chasing approvals, moving tickets). A spreadsheet is fine.
  2. Total the route column per client. If it is over half of billed time on a retainer, that retainer is mostly middle management, and it is the one most likely to be renegotiated.
  3. Automate the obvious routing. Meeting recaps, weekly status emails, ticket summaries and deadline reminders are the safe first targets. Keep a person reviewing anything a client reads. That kind of AI implementation frees hours without touching the relationship.
  4. Move freed hours into delivery. A project manager who also writes the migration plan, tests the release or owns the analytics setup is a player-coach. That role survives the Dorsey test, because it is not middle management in the old sense.
  5. Reprice around outcomes. Fixed scope with a defined deliverable is easier to defend than hours of coordination.
Two columns for the coordination audit: make hours such as coding and testing, route hours such as status calls and recaps
Two tags only. If route is over half of billed time on a retainer, that retainer is mostly middle management.

One caution. Automating coordination badly is worse than not doing it. A bot that sends a confident wrong status update to a client costs you more than a person who sends it late. Put quality gates on anything that leaves the building.

The work that survives the cut

When companies try to go lean on AI and hit the limits, they need people who can actually build, secure and run things. Not someone who manages people who know how. Someone who does it. If your agency is the technical capacity, a client's board can cut middle management everywhere else and still need you.

If your agency sells the work but does not build it, that is where a white-label development partner fits: the engineering sits behind your brand, and your team keeps the relationship and the strategy.

Frequently asked questions

What did Jack Dorsey say about middle management?

In "From Hierarchy to Intelligence," Dorsey and Roelof Botha argue that hierarchy and middle management slow information flow, and that AI can now do the coordination that layers of managers used to do.

How many jobs did Block cut in 2026?

Block said in February 2026 it was laying off more than 4,000 people, bringing its workforce to just under 6,000, and named AI tools as the reason.

Is AI actually replacing middle management?

Not at most companies yet. Large executive surveys show cuts made in anticipation of AI, and more than 90 percent of executives in one study report no employment effect so far.

Will companies rehire after AI layoffs?

Analysts expect many will. Gartner predicts half of companies that cut customer service staff due to AI will rehire by 2027, and Forrester expects half of AI-attributed layoffs to be reversed.

What should an agency do if clients question coordination fees?

Measure how many billed hours are middle management work, meaning coordination, versus delivery, automate routine status work with a person reviewing it, and price around defined deliverables instead of hours.

How should a Worcester or Shrewsbury team handle middle management and AI?

Most small teams in Worcester and Shrewsbury do not have a middle management layer to cut. The owner is the router: the person who answers the client, assigns the job and checks it went out. Adoption is still uneven by size. The Census Bureau found that 37% of firms with at least 250 employees reported using AI, while "Less than 20% of firms with four or fewer employees reported using AI." (U.S. Census Bureau (opens in a new tab)) So the Dorsey argument lands differently here. It is less about removing a tier and more about freeing the owner's week.

Where we fit

Kief Studio does the work: we build the site, application or system, and with white-label development your agency delivers it under your own name. We write the code, host it on dedicated infrastructure when the engagement calls for it, and stay out of the client relationship unless you bring us in. For the routing work in your own shop, our AI automation work builds quality-gated systems with a human path for anything the model is unsure about, and runs them for you on LTFI (opens in a new tab). We do not build projects meant to replace staff with AI. We remove bottlenecks, and your people drive the work.

First conversation is free. No commitment.

Tell us what your clients are asking about

Related articles

  1. Automate

    Managed AI Services: AI Staff Run for You on LTFI

    Managed AI services for a small business: AI staff set up and run for you on LTFI, with your rules, approvals and a log, and nothing to install.

    Amelia Gagne

  2. Automate

    AI Consulting in Massachusetts: What to Expect and Ask

    AI consulting in Massachusetts for a small business: what the work includes, what you should have running at the end, and which state rules apply.

    Brian Gagne

  3. Automate

    AI Implementation Timeline in Worcester: What We Set Up in the First Two Weeks

    Our AI implementation timeline for Worcester and Shrewsbury teams: one workflow, named approvers and a full log, day by day through the first two weeks.

    Amelia Gagne