- Published
- Updated
- 9 min read

TL;DR: In a 2023 survey, 91% of small business owners said they were labor hoarding, keeping staff through a slowdown rather than laying anyone off. Research shows hoarding firms survive more often but grow more slowly. The useful move is to spend that time getting knowledge out of people's heads and into systems, so the team is valuable for what it does next.
Updated October 2026: this note now cites each figure to its source and gives the survey's real date. We corrected what the survey said about owners' reasons, replaced old labor figures with the latest federal data, and removed stories and statistics we could not trace to a primary source.
Labor hoarding sounds like a criticism. It is not, or not only. Keeping good people through a slow stretch is often the right call. What I want to look at is why owners do it, what the research says it costs, and what a small business can do with the time it buys.
What is labor hoarding, and how common is it?
Labor hoarding means keeping more employees than current work needs, usually through a downturn, rather than laying people off and rehiring later. Skynova, an invoicing software company, surveyed 1,010 business owners going into 2023. "An astounding 91% of small-business owners said they're labor hoarding," and "89% were planning to keep it up in 2023." (Skynova (opens in a new tab)) The figures are self-reported, and the survey is now a few years old, so read them as a snapshot of owner sentiment rather than a current measurement.
Why owners said they hoard labor
The reasons were mostly about people. The most popular was "confidence in their current team's strength (48%)." Almost as many said layoffs hurt morale. "Seven in 10 small businesses also cited inflation and a potential recession as reasons to avoid laying off workers." On cost, "some small-business owners (over 40%) are labor hoarding to decrease their hiring and training costs." (Skynova (opens in a new tab))
An earlier version of this note said 43% of owners admitted they could not replace the knowledge their people carry. The survey does not say that. The cost reason it reports is about hiring and training, which is related but not the same thing. The knowledge question is real, and I come back to it below with its own source.
What owners did instead of layoffs
"Over half (60%) have conducted a hiring freeze," others "switched to remote work (53%) to cut office costs," and "Slightly fewer (48%) took that even further and reduced the work week to four days for some of their workers." Among small business owners, 67% said they would cut their own salaries to avoid laying anyone off. (Skynova (opens in a new tab)) That is a lot of personal cost to keep a team together.
Is labor hoarding still happening in 2026?
The national numbers look like a market where few people are let go and few are hired. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported for August 2026 that job openings were "little changed at 7.1 million," the hires rate "was 3.3 percent," and layoffs and discharges "changed little at 1.6 million and 1.0 percent." (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (opens in a new tab))
A low layoff rate next to a low hiring rate is consistent with employers holding on to the people they have. It does not prove labor hoarding on its own, and BLS does not call it that. But it matches what owners describe: keep the team, freeze new hires, wait.
We wrote about the hiring side of this in our note on labor becoming small businesses' top problem.
Does labor hoarding help or hurt a small business?
There is now peer-reviewed research on exactly this question. A 2026 paper in Small Business Economics looked at firms that kept more employees than predicted during the Great Recession and followed them for seven years. (Small Business Economics, via RePEc (opens in a new tab))
What the study found
The authors write: "We find that labor hoarding firms were significantly more likely to survive, with the effect strongest for women-owned and women-led businesses. However, these firms grew more slowly in both employment and sales than non-hoarding counterparts, who needed to rehire post-recession." They describe retaining workers as "workforce preservation," which provides "stability at the expense of rapid post-recession growth." (Small Business Economics, via RePEc (opens in a new tab))
Survival and growth are different goals
I read that as a trade, not a verdict. Labor hoarding buys survival. It does not buy growth on its own. The study does not say why hoarding firms grew more slowly, so I will not pretend it does. What I can say from the work we do is that a team held together through a slow year is an asset only if the time is used to make the business easier to run.
What is the knowledge problem behind labor hoarding?
Every small business has someone who is the only person who knows how a thing works. The vendor portal, the quirky client, the month-end report, the reason a setting is the way it is. When that person leaves, the knowledge leaves too.
There is research on how big this gap is, with a caveat. A 2018 survey sponsored by Panopto, a video platform company, found that "42% of institutional knowledge is unique to employees in their role and not shared with coworkers," so if they leave, "colleagues can't perform 42% of their job." It also found knowledge workers "waste 5.3 hours a week waiting for crucial information from coworkers or recreating information that already exists." (HR Dive (opens in a new tab)) That survey covered larger employers, not small shops. In a business of eight people, I would expect the share to be higher, not lower, but that is my judgment, not a measurement. That gap is what labor hoarding quietly insures against.
Replacing a person costs more than a salary
Gallup puts the cost plainly: "The cost of replacing an individual employee can range from one-half to two times the employee's annual salary," and calls that "a conservative estimate." (Gallup (opens in a new tab)) Part of that cost is recruiting and training. Part of it is the knowledge that has to be rebuilt from scratch.
So labor hoarding is often a reasonable bet. It is cheaper to keep a person than to replace one. The problem is that the bet only pays while nobody leaves, retires, gets sick or takes a real vacation.
What happens when the owner is the knowledge?
The same problem sits at the top of many small businesses. Gallup, using Census data, reports that "just over half (52.3%) of U.S. employer-businesses are owned by people who are at or near retirement age, those 55 and older." (Gallup (opens in a new tab)) The Census Bureau's own graphic from an earlier survey year says the same thing: "Over Half of U.S. Business Owners Were Age 55 and Over." (U.S. Census Bureau (opens in a new tab))
Gallup also asked about plans. "When asked about long-term plans for their business after they step away, a third of all business owners say they have no plan or are unsure about their future." (Gallup (opens in a new tab))
A business that depends on the owner's memory is hard to hand to anyone. We looked at how buyers price that in our note on what buyers now pay for.
How do you turn labor hoarding into an advantage?
If you are already labor hoarding, you have paid for spare capacity. Here is how I would spend it.
Run the vacation test
Pick your most relied on person and imagine they are gone for two weeks with no phone. List what would stop. That list is your first project. Then do the same for yourself.
Write down decisions, not just steps
Most documentation fails because it records clicks and skips reasons. For each recurring task, capture what triggers it, what good looks like, the two or three exceptions that come up, and who to ask when something looks wrong. A one page note with the reasoning beats a forty page manual nobody opens.
Put the knowledge where the work happens
A wiki in a separate app tends to go stale. Knowledge gets used when it sits next to the work: in the project, the client record, the ticket. This is the idea behind knowledge systems, search over your own documents and data that shows where each answer came from. We wrote about the same problem from the tool side in our note on automation that lives in one person's browser tabs.
Move shared logins and vendor contacts out of heads
Put shared credentials in a password manager with more than one owner. Keep a single list of vendors, accounts and renewal dates. This is unglamorous and it is the work that hurts most when it is missing.
Cross train in pairs
Pair each critical task with a second person who does it once a month while the first person watches. The goal is not two experts. It is one person who can keep it running for a week, so labor hoarding stops being the only safety net.
Automate after you document, not before
Once a process is written down and repeatable, parts of it may be good candidates for automation. Before that, automation just hides the undocumented parts. I wrote about choosing those tasks in our note on deciding what to automate, and about building systems before you need them (opens in a new tab) on my own site.
Is labor hoarding loyalty or risk?
It can be both. Keeping your people through a slow year is loyal. Keeping them because the business would break without them is a risk you are carrying for them and for yourself. If your best person cannot take two weeks off without something falling over, that is not a reward for their work. It is a dependency.
The kindest version of labor hoarding is the one where you use the time to make every role easier to step into. Your people stay valuable for what they do next, not for what only they remember.
Frequently asked questions
What is labor hoarding?
Labor hoarding is keeping more employees than current work needs, usually through a slowdown, instead of laying people off and rehiring when demand returns.
How many small businesses are labor hoarding?
In a survey of 1,010 business owners going into 2023, 91% of small business owners said they were labor hoarding. The figures are self-reported and a few years old.
Is labor hoarding good or bad for a business?
Both. A 2026 study in Small Business Economics found labor hoarding firms were more likely to survive the Great Recession but grew more slowly in employment and sales afterward.
Why do small businesses hoard labor?
Owners in the survey cited confidence in their team, morale, inflation and recession worries, and the cost of hiring and training replacements.
How much does it cost to replace an employee?
Gallup estimates one half to two times the employee's annual salary, and calls that conservative.
How do I protect my business from knowledge loss?
Run a two week vacation test for key people, write down decisions and exceptions, keep knowledge next to the work, share critical logins safely and cross train in pairs.
Where we fit
Kief Studio builds knowledge systems for teams whose answers already exist in shared drives, wikis, tickets and email but take too long to find. We gather the sources, decide with you who is allowed to see what, index the content so search understands meaning, and return answers with the source document attached so anyone can check them. We host it and keep the index current. We run this on LTFI, where your contacts, projects and AI staff share one system that Kief Studio runs for you.
If labor hoarding has bought you a quieter quarter and you are not sure where to start, our technology advisory work reviews what you run today and writes the order of steps in plain language.
First conversation is free. No commitment.




